TonyMolyGel Eyeliner, 01 Black

I received the Tony Moly eyeliner gel today. It came in a plastic zip lock bag, with the lid removed. It's fine since it is in a zip lock bag and no smear or spillage since it's gel. What I am disappointed is that the brush that supposed to come with it, is missing. How am I suppose to use it ? What I don't understand is why sellers don't check the items before sending ? If sellers wants customer to give 5 stars then PLS check the items to see if there is any defects or any missing part, before mailing out. The product is pretty good since it doesn't smudge, need to let it dry. It's pretty pigmented. That jar can last for some time. Since the brush is missing, the product is expensive, that's how I think. I do not wish to return, cuz it's such a hassle. That's why I give only 3 stars. However, If you can send me the brush, you can get a 5 star !

I've been using Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner for about 10 years. Due to some recent budgeting and savings goals, I decided to cut back on some of my high-end makeup and was looking for alternatives. ($32 is a lot for eyeliner!) I used this Tony Moly eyeliner in my early 20s while living in Korea, and I remembered it being pretty good, so I wanted to give it another shot. I wasn't expecting it to be anything close to Bobbi Brown, but I was pleasantly surprised! It goes on super black, formula is smooth, and extremely long lasting. I highly recommend it for anyone who's looking for a great affordable gel eyeliner!

I didn’t enjoy the color transfer from the eyeliner to the top of my eyes. It smeared a lot and didn’t really leave an even color (very faint too!) they refunded me when I didn’t want to keep the product so I know the seller is kind and understanding.

I asked a friend of mine what type of eyeliner she used because it looked so good on her & she shared her secret -Tonymoly! I love the color and how it goes on so smooth! Lasts all day long even though I have oily skin and the brush it comes with makes it a lot easier to do a "cat eye"! A little goes a long way, so this will be sure to last me a long time.

So I typically have always hated gel eyeliner, but I wanted to try again after a decade and saw a good review for this online. Loved the cap too.The cap is amazing and super useful for the moments you need to set your liner down. Pigment is gorgeous, and goes on smooth and soft. It's a steal for the price honestly. It's changed me from a hater to a lover of gel eyeliner with how easy it is. I DID struggle the first use, but realized during the second use it was much easier because the brush had tapered itself with the remnants of the first session.Overall this is fantastic and I would definitely recommend it for beginners to gel and eyeliner in general!